Linguapress Intermediate English
Advanced level reading resources Intermediate reading resources English grammar online Language games and puzzles Intermediate English

Dr. Trelew's encounter - a Victorian mystery

A short story in intermediate level English 

WITH AUDIO: ► Click to open/close audio player then hit the ► play button

    I'm not sure how to begin this story, because I don't know if people will want to believe it; but I can assure you that it happened to me, Dr. Jonas Trelew, of St. Austell, Cornwall, on the night of 28th January in the year 1891.
Dr Trelew's encounter    It was a cold evening, and I was returning home on my horse, after a long and busy afternoon.
     There was an epidemic of whooping cough in the coun­ty at that time, and I had been seeing patients all day long. Alas, three children had died the pre­vious day in the Pengelly family at Treviscoe, and many people were frightened for their young chil­dren.
    As I rode along the highway between Roche and Carthew, I was surprised to see a light coming along behind me in the dark. As the moon came out from behind a cloud, I could make out two gallop­ing horsemen, one holding a light in his hand.  At first I imagined that they had been sent out to bring me back to help some other sick person in one of the vil­lages I had just visited.
    As the two riders approached, I felt a moment of apprehension. I was on a lonely part of the road across the moorland. I spurred my own horse to a trot, and grabbed the pistol I always carried with me when riding out alone in winter.
    I need not have worried; as the men came up to me, they slowed down, and I saw by the light of the lantern that one was my old friend the lawyer, William Trelawney. That surprised me a lit­tle, as I thought he was in Oxford at the time. Had he not told me at Christmas that he would not be returning to Cornwall before the Spring? Yet there was no doubt it was him; we had been friends for four years, and I recognized him instantly.
    The other man had a thin face and very heavy eye­brows, and I thought he looked ill.  Strangely, I did not recognize him, though I knew most of the faces for miles around Saint Austell. I presumed he must be a friend of William's from Oxford or else­where.
    "William!" I said, "What brings you here at this time of night on this road?"
    But instead of answering my question, the man lifted his light and shone it in my face. It shone in his face too, and I saw him start, as if with surprise. "I'm sorry Sir," he said, and before I had time to re­act to his strange words, he called to his companion, saying "Come on Walter", and the two rode off into the dark.
    This strange encounter left me feeling some­what anxious; and not wanting to have any more bizarre experiences, I made for home as fast as I could.
    Within a few days, the incident had gone right out of my mind. Evidently the man I had seen was not William Trelawney, just someone who looked very similar to him, when seen by the light of a lantern on a cold January evening.

* * *
    A couple of months later, William Trelawney came down by train from Oxford, for Easter. I first noticed him in church on Good Friday, sitting a couple of rows behind me on the other side, his us­ual place. But as I looked at him, I felt the blood going cold in my back. There was the man who had pass­ed me on the moor that Jan­uary night. There was no doubt about it.
.    After the service, we met outside the pub among the crowd of people.
    "Well," I said, as I shook William's hand. But I couldn't think what to say next.
    "Hello Jonas," he replied, "It's good to see you".
    I felt more at ease; this was more like William Trelawney, my old friend. We got into conversation, as we had many times before.
    Then he said something that made my blood go cold again.
    "You know, something very strange happened to me last January; I wish you'd been there to help," he said. "My clerk, Walter Burns, got taken ill all of a sudden one evening. We were returning to­gether at the time from an appointment several miles out of town. He seemed to be in great pain, so we went back to Oxford as fast as we could, to get him to a doctor. On the road, we passed another man on horseback. I was just going to ask him if there was a doctor nearby, when I saw that he looked just like you, Jonas. Just like you. I was so sur­prised, I thought it was you. It gave me the fright of my life;  words stuck in my throat, and I just murmured an excuse, and we rode on, back to Ox­ford.
     I'm afraid it was too late; Doctor Mercer in Oxford could not tell what Walter was suffering from, and the poor fellow died two days later. I'm sure you could have saved him."
    "And what did your clerk Walter look like," I asked?
    "Why do you ask?" William replied.
    "Out of curiosity."
    "Well, he was a tall young man, with very dark eyebrows."

    I have never told William about my encounter.

Word guide
WORDS: encounter: meeting - whooping cough: a dangerous form of cough - previous day: the day before - rode: past tense of to ride - make out: distinguish, see - make out: just see - apprehension: anxiety - lonely: isolated - moorland: open tree-less hilltops - spur on: make a horse go faster - eyebrows: hair above the eyes - start: react with surprise - make for: go in the di­rection of - Good Friday - the Friday before Easter Sunday - service: mass - at ease: not anxious - clerk: secretary - got taken ill: became ill - appointment: meeting, rendezvous.

Return to Linguapress site index

Printing: Optimized for printing
© Linguapress.  Do not copy this document to any other website
Copying permitted for personal study, or by teachers for use with their students


Student Worksheet

Dr. Trelew's encounter
1. True or false ? Say whether these statements are true or false:

    1.    Trelew was on his way home after visiting the Pengelly family.
    2.    The two horsemen were travelling in the same direction as he was.
    3.    Trelew didn't usually ride alone at night in winter.
    4.    Trelew thought that William Trelawney had gone to Oxford a few days before.
    5.    Trelew was surprised because the rider didn't recognise him.
    6.    William Trelawney came home a few days before Easter.
    7.    Walter Burns was a young man.
    8.    Walter died because he did not see Dr. Mercer in time.

2. Word search:  read through the text and find:
    1.    the names of three public holidays.
    2.    three words referring to health
    3.    eight parts of the body.
    4.    three words associated with horses.
    5.     at least eight words that help set the tone for this strange tale.

3 . In the story there is both direct and indirect speech. Try and rewrite the sections in 1st person direct speech, in indi­rect speech.

4.Writing exercise: rewrite the ending: remove the last one-line paragraph of the article, and continue the story as if Trelawney did tell William about his encounter.

Notes for teachers

A. Listening comprehension: have pupils follow the text as you play it through, then answer the comprehension questions . At the same time, ask them have pupils follow the text as you play it through, then answer the comprehension questions. At the same time, ask them to pick out the number of differ­ences (about a dozen) between the written version of the story and the recorded text. How important is each differ­ence?
This story is adapted from an original that was well known at the end of the 19th century. It is set in Cornwall, in the extreme south west of England, an area famous for its ghosts and Celtic legends

Other ideas?
EFL teachers: Help develop this resource by contributing extra teaching materials or exercises.
To contribute click here for further details
This teaching resource is © copyright Linguapress Revised 2021 . Originally published in Freeway, the Intermediate level English newsmagazine.
Republication on other websites or in print is not authorised 

Linguapress; home Découvrez l'Angleterre (en français) Discover Britain


Intermediate level EFL resource
Level Intermediate.
CEFR LEVEL :  B1 intermediate
IELTS Level :  4 - 5
Flesch-Kincaid  scores
Reading ease level:   81  Easy
Grade level: 6

Reading resources in graded English
from Linguapress
Selected pages
Intermediate resources :
The legendary Mini Cooper
Is Britain really different ?
Life in the Scottish Highlands
Who is James Bond ?
USA: Who was Buffalo Bill?
USA: Close encounters with a Twister  
More: More intermediate reading texts  
Advanced level reading :
Charles Babbage, the father of the computer
Who killed Martin Luther King?
The story of the jet plane
Tolkien - the man who gave us the Hobbit
More: More advanced reading texts  
Selected grammar pages
Verbs in English
Noun groups in English
Word order in English
Reported questions in English
Language and style 
Word stress in English
The short story of English

Copyright notice.

Text, photos and worksheet © copyright Linguapress 2020.

Multi-copying of this resource is permitted for classroom use. In schools declaring the source of copied materials to a national copyright agency, Linguapress intermediate level resources should be attributed to "Freeway" as the source and "Linguapresss" as the publisher.

Free to view, free to share,  free to use in class, free to print, but not free to copy..
If you like this page and want to share it with others,  just share a link, don't copy.

Linguapress respects your privacy and does not collect personal data. We use cookies only to log anonymous visitor stats and enable essential page functions. To remove this message click   , otherwise click for more details